Increasing glacier thickness by local artificial snow production

Ice sheets and glaciers

Up to 50% of the world’s glaciers are set to disappear this century, with many more at risk if emission reduction targets are not met (Rounce et al. 2023).

Oerlemans et al. (2017) suggested using localized surface technologies to create artificial snow cover on mountain glaciers. Financed by a Swiss grant, there are currently ongoing experiments to explore the feasibility of other such technologies on the Swiss Morteratsch glacier (see MortAlive, Glaciers Alive, and Cover Project Foundation).

Technological Readiness Level (TRL)

Medium 2

Due to reduced amounts of snowfall, many of the world’s ski resorts are already heavily reliant on artificial snow (Gerbaux et al. 2020; Joksimović 2021). Amongst several snow producing methods, snow cannons are the most common. This is effective on a local scale (Fischer et al. 2016), although it requires large amounts of energy and water. Alternatively, less wealthy ski areas sometimes resort to so-called snow farming, in which previously fallen snow is stored and redistributed when needed (Wolfsperger et al. 2019). The MortAlive project seeks to use technologies that do not require external energy sources or water from a glacial lake. They collaborate with several Swiss commercial companies in this endeavour.

Technological Readiness Level (TRL)

A technology with a TRL of 4-6: TRL 4 – validated in lab; TRL 5 – validated in relevant environment; TRL 6 – demonstrated in relevant environment

Scalability

Low 1

As with other mountain glacier stabilization techniques (see, for example, Huss et al. 2021; and Stabilizing glaciers by cloud seeding), the technical requirements - especially the cost - make such technologies relevant only for particularly valuable glaciers and not feasibly scalable.

Scalability

Physically unable to scale; sub-linear/logarithmic efficiency of scalability

Timeliness for near-future effects

High 3

Snowmaking technology already exists and ongoing experiments, like the one on Morteratsch, will likely provide clear answers on how to best employ it.

Timeliness for near-future effects

Implemented in time to make a significant difference

Northern + Arctic potential

Low 1

The technology might be applied to help slow the melt of particularly valued glaciers, but due to technical requirements - especially the cost - such technologies would only be deployable on particularly valuable glaciers, if at all.

Northern + Arctic potential

No noticeable extra positive effect beyond the global average; technology is unsuited to the Arctic

Global potential

Low 1

Mountain glaciers store enough water to cause about 50-60 cm of global sea level rise. However, given the described uncertainties around effectiveness and difficulties with scalability, increasing glacier mass would likely not have a significant global impact.

Global potential

Insignificant to be detected at a global scale

Cost - benefit

High 1

Abermann et al. (2022) clearly show that most glacier stabilization techniques are far too costly for almost all of the world's glaciers, even the most visited ones.

Cost - benefit

Cost of investment comparable to cost of avoided damage

Environmental risks

Low 3

Such measures are already commonplace in ski resorts which generally have strong incentives to avoid damage and are under close scrutiny. The projects named above emphasize their use of technologies that do not require external water and energy sources, potentially preventing negative environmental side effects.

Environmental risks

Very limited, site-specific effects restricted to the solution deployment location only

Community impacts

Beneficial 3

Some of the sites on which this technique would be deployed might be of particular importance to local communities. For instance because of religious or financial reasons, or because it is a source of drinking water. The protection of such a glacier could therefore be important to such a community. Although it has to be ensured that the water and energy requirements of this measure would not interfere with local needs.

Community impacts

Significant benefits to communities

Ease of reversibility

Medium 2

This measure would probably be reversible by default, but the thickened glacier would only slowly return to its original state. It would likely have to be deployed constantly to prevent a sudden warming of the glacier under normal climatic circumstances.

Ease of reversibility

Possible with significant investment

Risk of termination shock

Low 3

Risk of termination shock

Low or insignificant termination shock or damage

Legality/governance

High 3

It would mainly be a local issue, and artificial snow making is already practiced at ski resorts worldwide.

Legality/governance

Currently legal to deploy, with governance structures in place to facilitate it and/or financial incentives to develop it

Scientific/media attention

Medium 2

The suggestion by Oerlemans et al (2017) has received quite a lot of attention in the international media. Given the large financial importance of winter tourism, future funding and interest in such measures are likely to rise.

Scientific/media attention

Some attention within the scientific community, including published research and funding programmes; some media attention; some commercial interest

References

Abermann, J., Theurl, M., Frei, E., Hynek, B., Schöner, W., & Steininger, K. W. (2022). Too expensive to keep—bidding farewell to an iconic mountain glacier?. Regional Environmental Change. 22(2): 51. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-022-01912-4

Fischer, A., Helfricht, K., & Stocker-Waldhuber, M. (2016). Local reduction of decadal glacier thickness loss through mass balance management in ski resorts. The Cryosphere, 10(6), 2941-2952. https://doi.org/10.5194/tc-10-2941-2016

Gerbaux, M., Spandre, P., François, H., George, E., & Morin, S. (2020). Snow reliability and water availability for snowmaking in the ski resorts of the Isere departement (French Alps), under current and future climate conditions. Journal of Alpine Research| Revue de géographie alpine, (108-1). https://doi.org/10.4000/rga.6742

Huss, M., Schwyn, U., Bauder, A., & Farinotti, D. (2021). Quantifying the overall effect of artificial glacier melt reduction in Switzerland, 2005–2019. Cold Regions Science and Technology, 184, 103237. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.coldregions.2021.103237

Joksimović, M., Gajić, M., Vujadinović, S., Milenković, J., & Malinić, V. (2021). Artificial snowmaking: Winter sports between state-owned company policy and tourist demand. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research, 45(7), 1170-1187. https://doi.org/10.1177/1096348020957072

Oerlemans, J., Haag, M., & Keller, F. (2017). Slowing down the retreat of the Morteratsch glacier, Switzerland, by artificially produced summer snow: a feasibility study. Climatic Change, 145(1-2), 189-203. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-017-2102-1

Rounce, D. R., Hock, R., Maussion, F., Hugonnet, R., Kochtitzky, W., Huss, M., ... & McNabb, R. W. (2023). Global glacier change in the 21st century: Every increase in temperature matters. Science, 379(6627), 78-83. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abo1324

Wolfsperger, F., Rhyner, H., & Schneebeli, M. (2019). Slope preparation and grooming. A handbook for practitioners.WSL Institute of Snow and Avalanche Research SLF. ISBN: 978-3-905621-59-4. 232pp.

Related ideas

Old whale bone providing fertile conditions for vascular plants, Antarctic Peninsula

Industry

Biochar

The concentration of GHGs in the atmosphere will have to be stabilized or lowered to mitigate or even reverse current global warming. To achieve this, current GHG emissions need to be reduced. Such mitigation strategies will however take time to deploy, and some emission sources will be difficult to mitigate. Moreover, since current atmospheric levels are already having a major warming effect, negative emission or Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) measures that reduce the amount of GHGs in the atmosphere are an active topic of research.

Shelf-Iceberg, North of Antarctic Peninsula

Ice sheets and glaciers

Ice sheet stabilization via buttressing

One of the potentially most catastrophic effects of contemporary global warming would be the dramatic increase in sea levels as a result of the melting Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets. Even if all current emissions were immediately stopped, sea level rise could still occur because of lockedin warming (State of the Cryosphere report 2022).

Fishing boat in between icebergs, Disco Bay, Greenland

Oceans & marine

Improved fishing practices and management

Fisheries contribute to global CO2 emissions by the extraction of fish, disturbance of coastal and oceanic blue carbon ecosystems, and the use of fossil fuels as their main energy source. Fishing vessels are moreover a major source of short-lived climate forcers like black carbon (McKuin and Campbell 2016), which can have a major effect in Arctic and Northern regions (see Black carbon reduction).

Industry

Atmospheric methane removal: Solar chimney and photocatalytic semiconductor technology

Methane is a highly potent greenhouse gas and its reduction is given ever greater priority in international emission reduction policies (see, for example, https://www.globalmethanepledge.org/). There are several suggested ways to remove atmospheric methane (see Nisbet Jones et al. 2021; and Ming et al. 2022; see in this report also iron salt aerosols and zeolites). One of the main issues with methane removal is that atmospheric methane concentrations are very low. This means that very large volumes of air, and related energy demands, are required, making the use of ventilators like those used for DACCS (see direct air capture) more complicated (Nisbet-Jones et al. 2021).

Land-based measures

Enhancing permafrost refreezing with air pipes

Large areas of the Northern and Arctic regions consist of permafrost, almost permanently frozen soil. As global temperatures rise, these permafrost areas are thawing at an ever faster rate. This thawing leads to massive amounts of GHGs being released into the atmosphere, as carbon stored in the permafrost is converted into methane by bacteria. Because methane is a very potent GHG, the thawing of the permafrost is considered a major tipping point in the climatic system. Permafrost preservation is of the utmost importance because Arctic terrestrial regions alone hold up to 1500 Pg C (Schuur et al. 2015), and although there is large uncertainty about the total amount of emissions from permafrost (Miner et al. 2022), especially when it comes to nonlinear abrupt thawing (Turetsky et al. 2020), significant amounts of carbon release is to be expected as the Northern regions warm.

Coastal Archipelago Park of the South Coast ("Sørlandet") of Norway, colors at the shoreline (1)

Oceans & marine

Artificial downwelling

Oceans play an important role in global heat transfer and carbon storage processes. As global temperatures and atmospheric carbon levels rise, some have suggested artificially modifying the vertical movement of water to enhance these processes.

Industry

Radiative covering and building technologies/ Passive daytime radiative cooling

An increase in GHGs in the atmosphere leads to a greater amount of outgoing infrared radiation from the earth being retained. There are several ideas to reduce the resulting warming by modifying surface radiation processes.

High waves at Tromøy shore, "Rollingstone" (Raet) National Park in planning, Arendal

Oceans & marine

Hydrological system modification - Ocean current modification

Hydrological systems play an important role in energy distribution in the climate system. For the Arctic and Northern region the clearest example of this is the habitability of the European Arctic thanks to the Gulf Stream. Furthermore, there are several access points to the Arctic ocean that play an important role in shaping local geophysical conditions.